I thought long and hard trying to make a choice between these and the 3D Maxpiders. I even asked a friend's opinion. Finally, I decided to use these on the front and rear seats and use the Maxpiders in the cargo area.Gosh, I am glad I did. Since I don't live in a harsh climate and I don't use my car for anything more than going to work and gym, I don't need the heavy duty Maxpiders. The Autailors are a nice colorful, tasteful touch of class.I really like the red in my black MYP. They fit perfectly in rear passenger floor and the front passenger side. The driver's side is just ever so slightly off but it is not noticeable and does not bother me in the least. The foot well is covered where my feet plant when I drive so I am quite happy with this product.This review is for the 5 seat version of this product.